text.skipToContent text.skipToNavigation

Orders over $99 ship FREE - use code SHIP99 excluded

May Supplies

69 item(s)

Filter Products

Shop by Badge

On Sale (2)
Clearance (2)
Out of Stock (15)

Shop by size

12 in. (2)
9 in. x 12 in. (1)

Shop by brand

Colorations® (32)
Con-Tact® (1)
Do-A-Dot Art™ (1)
Environments® (1)
EPI (1)
Excellerations® (18)
Learning Resources® (1)
Little Folk Visuals (1)
Melissa & Doug® (1)
MyPerfectClassroom® (1)
Officemate (2)
Pacon® (4)
Roylco® (1)
TickiT® (1)
Ticonderoga® (1)

show all show less

Shop by Age

2 yrs. (10)
3 yrs. (37)
4 yrs. (39)
5 yrs. (38)
6 yrs. (31)
7 yrs. (20)
8 yrs. (18)
9 yrs. (11)
10 yrs. (11)
11 yrs. (10)
12 yrs. (10)
18 mos. (3)
Teens (5)

show all show less

Shop by Grade

Toddler (10)
PreK (40)
Grade K (38)
Grade 1 (31)
Grade 2 (20)
Grade 3 (18)
Grade 4 (11)
Grade 5 (11)
Grade 6 (10)
Grade 7 (10)
Grade 8+ (5)

show all show less

Shop by Dropship

Stock Product (69)

Shop by color

Black (5)
Blue (5)
Brown (4)
Gray (3)
Green (5)
Multi or Assorted (2)
Orange (5)
Pink (5)
Purple (5)
Red (5)
White (5)
Yellow (5)

show all show less

Shop by Price

$0.00 - $99.99 (63)
$100 - $499.99 (6)

Shop by Review

(65)
(1)
(3)

1-24 of 69 items

Items per page

Sort by

«
‹
1(current)
2
3
›
»

Colorations® Paraben-Free Simply Washable Tempera Paint- Gallon

$16.99

(54)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint--gallon/p/2026 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint--gallon/p/2016 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint--gallon/p/2017 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint--gallon/p/2018 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint--gallon/p/2019

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® 9" x 12" Mediumweight Construction Paper - 50 sheets

$1.49

(50)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/construction-paper/colorations-9--x-12--mediumweight-construction-paper---50-sheets/p/458 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/construction-paper/colorations-9--x-12--mediumweight-construction-paper---50-sheets/p/459 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/construction-paper/colorations-9--x-12--mediumweight-construction-paper---50-sheets/p/460 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/construction-paper/colorations-9--x-12--mediumweight-construction-paper---50-sheets/p/461 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/construction-paper/colorations-9--x-12--mediumweight-construction-paper---50-sheets/p/462

+14

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Washable White School Glue - Gallons

$19.99-$29.99

(497)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/glue/glue-adhesives/colorations-washable-white-school-glue---gallons/p/S697207 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/glue/glue-adhesives/colorations-washable-white-school-glue---gallons/p/2266

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Paraben-Free Simply Washable Tempera Paint - 16 oz.

$4.75

(16)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint---16-oz-/p/3639 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint---16-oz-/p/3629 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint---16-oz-/p/3630 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint---16-oz-/p/3631 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/tempera-paint/colorations-paraben-free-simply-washable-tempera-paint---16-oz-/p/3632

+14

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Pom-Poms - 1 lb. Value Pack

$29.99

(126)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Butcher Paper Rolls

$82.99-$99.99

(14)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/butcher-paper-paper-rolls/colorations-butcher-paper-rolls/p/286 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/butcher-paper-paper-rolls/colorations-butcher-paper-rolls/p/285 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paper-paper-rolls/butcher-paper-paper-rolls/colorations-butcher-paper-rolls/p/287

Get it May 31 - Jun 02, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Repositionable Con-Tact® Cover, 18"W x 50 ft.L

$39.99

(51)

Get it May 28 - May 30, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Excellerations® Tender Touch Baby Dolls - Set of 4

$98.99

(53)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Acrylic Yarn - Set of 12

$59.99

(41)

Notify Me When Available

Please enter your email address to be notified when this product becomes available.

Email Address

Please enter a valid email

Cancel

Thanks! We'll notify you when this item becomes available.

Continue Shopping

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Stamper-Perfect Washable Stamp Pads - Set of 12

$19.99

(103)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Paraben-Free Washable Finger Paints - 10 Colors, 16 fl oz each

$43.50

(96)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

White Cardstock - 100 Sheets

$10.99

(49)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Bright Buttons

$17.99-$85.99

(50)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/collage-mosaic/bright-buttons/p/1717 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/collage-mosaic/bright-buttons/p/1731

Get it Jun 07 - Jun 09, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Regular Wood Craft Sticks - 1000 Pieces

$14.99

(1)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Paraben-Free BioColor® Paint - 16oz

$6.99

(4)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/acrylic-paint-specialty-paint/colorations-paraben-free-biocolor-paint---16oz/p/763 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/acrylic-paint-specialty-paint/colorations-paraben-free-biocolor-paint---16oz/p/754 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/acrylic-paint-specialty-paint/colorations-paraben-free-biocolor-paint---16oz/p/755 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/acrylic-paint-specialty-paint/colorations-paraben-free-biocolor-paint---16oz/p/756 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/paint-paint-tools/acrylic-paint-specialty-paint/colorations-paraben-free-biocolor-paint---16oz/p/759

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Premium White Washable Glue Sticks, (ea. 0.17 oz)

$26.59-$112.00

(45)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/glue/glue-adhesives/colorations-premium-white-washable-glue-sticks--ea-0-17-oz-/p/33684 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/glue/glue-adhesives/colorations-premium-white-washable-glue-sticks--ea-0-17-oz-/p/S679417 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/glue/glue-adhesives/colorations-premium-white-washable-glue-sticks--ea-0-17-oz-/p/S679425

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Excellerations® Ladies’ and Gentlemen’s Dress-Up Set 24 Pieces

$189.99

(4)

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Extra-Safe Plastic Glitter - 1lb.

$18.99

(19)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/foam-feathers-sparkles/colorations-extra-safe-plastic-glitter---1lb-/p/1933 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/foam-feathers-sparkles/colorations-extra-safe-plastic-glitter---1lb-/p/1919 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/foam-feathers-sparkles/colorations-extra-safe-plastic-glitter---1lb-/p/1930 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/foam-feathers-sparkles/colorations-extra-safe-plastic-glitter---1lb-/p/1931 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/foam-feathers-sparkles/colorations-extra-safe-plastic-glitter---1lb-/p/1938

Get it May 22, 2026

Order in the next 5 hrs and 53 mins

Added to Your Wishing Well

Colorations® Blunt Tip Scissors, 5"L

$1.99-$37.99

(13)

https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/scissors/colorations-blunt-tip-scissors-5-l/p/S911582 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/scissors/colorations-blunt-tip-scissors-5-l/p/15507 https://www.discountschoolsupply.com/arts-crafts/arts-crafts-supplies/scissors/colorations-blunt-tip-scissors-5-l/p/S665392